Problem and BCH usefulness
The historical campaigns proposed education, community building, merchant adoption and East–West coordination. The retained scopes establish the intended BCH problem, not a current effectiveness rating. [8]
The historical campaigns proposed education, community building, merchant adoption and East–West coordination. The retained scopes establish the intended BCH problem, not a current effectiveness rating.
Project overview & BCH-1 report · combines linked funding rounds, commitments and results. Each campaign retains its own proposal review; funding success does not establish delivery.
Recorded campaigns only; historical coverage has not been established as complete. The BCH and historical USD figures cover linked records, not lifetime project funding.
2 of 2 recorded funded campaigns priced at their own dates. 0 use archive dates rather than confirmed funding dates. Daily reference prices, not actual USD proceeds or today’s value.
The historical campaigns proposed education, community building, merchant adoption and East–West coordination. The retained scopes establish the intended BCH problem, not a current effectiveness rating. [8]
BitcoinCashOG, La Economía P2P and local merchant programmes are potential comparators, but differences in years, languages and outcomes require historical evidence. No current uniqueness or failure claim is made from a sparse archive. [8]
The creator’s surviving read.cash archive demonstrates historical publication activity. Current reach and campaign-attributable retained merchant activity were not established. Surviving publication archive is not a retained-merchant/adoption dataset. [8]
Eligible recorded funding: 829.53850000 BCH; approximately $391,337.00 using retained historical USD reference prices. These are funding equivalents, not actual expenditure. A zero eligible subtotal with missing funding records does not mean zero development cost. Unconfirmed dates and grace-window rounds are excluded. [8]
The original campaign hosts were unavailable and the current former homepage is parked for sale. Surviving historical posts do not establish full campaign fulfillment. All unresolved scope remains unassessed, not failed; remove the legacy low aggregate driven by missing evidence. [8]
The two historical awards have recorded funding, but complete scope and period-matched outputs remain unavailable. This specific evidence gap prevents value judgment; it is not a blanket rejection of creator-reported outcomes. [8]
The surviving creator archive contains dated weekly publications. Its 29 May 2023 post explicitly hands the newsletter to the Bitcoin Cash Foundation. This establishes a documented publication handover, not an unexplained disappearance. Campaign-level closeouts and the wider organization’s continuity remain unresolved, so a comprehensive accountability score is not assigned. [8]
Assessment revision bch1-autonomous-v2-2026-11-12-applicability. Source refresh is bounded; HTTP success is not claim verification. Unavailable/JS-only sources do not erase accepted evidence. Ratings express anchored judgments, not precise measured completion percentages. Analyst simulation: primary-source claims and retained campaign evidence; independent on-chain spending, full deployment testing and matched peer-cost/usage datasets are not established. Original campaign identities and recorded completion states are preserved. Unassessed work is neither failed nor delivered. [8]
Extracted commitments and source-reported achievements. A passed target date or funded campaign does not establish delivery.
Tracked-item counts do not measure full scope coverage or the relative value of each outcome.
4 items not yet assessed. Missing evidence review does not establish non-delivery.
Included in score · eligible 2022-05-24
Campaign 52fb481bc473d44d · 2021-11-24
Autonomous summary0 of 4 tracked items complete (reported, verified or explicitly presumed); 4 unassessed. These are raw counts, not economic weights or proof of full scope coverage. Eligible for this dated assessment; unknown scope is not a failed commitment.
Extracted from the historical campaign description. Detailed acceptance criteria and delivery artifacts have not been reconciled. [4]
Source target: No date statedExtracted from the historical campaign description. Detailed acceptance criteria and delivery artifacts have not been reconciled. [4]
Source target: No date statedExtracted from the historical campaign description. Detailed acceptance criteria and delivery artifacts have not been reconciled. [4]
Source target: No date statedExtracted from the historical campaign description. Detailed acceptance criteria and delivery artifacts have not been reconciled. [4]
Source target: No date statedTracked-item counts do not measure full scope coverage or the relative value of each outcome.
3 items not yet assessed. Missing evidence review does not establish non-delivery.
Included in score · eligible 2021-04-19
Campaign 84eed4e438825033 · 2020-10-19
Autonomous summary0 of 3 tracked items complete (reported, verified or explicitly presumed); 3 unassessed. These are raw counts, not economic weights or proof of full scope coverage. Eligible for this dated assessment; unknown scope is not a failed commitment.
Extracted from the historical campaign description. Detailed acceptance criteria and delivery artifacts have not been reconciled. [3]
Source target: No date statedExtracted from the historical campaign description. Detailed acceptance criteria and delivery artifacts have not been reconciled. [3]
Source target: No date statedExtracted from the historical campaign description. Detailed acceptance criteria and delivery artifacts have not been reconciled. [3]
Source target: No date statedProfile revision 5 · updated 2026-11-12 · Initial research snapshot
Live fetch 2026-09-22; domain marketplace listing observed, no project content.
Atlas registry status for satoshis-angels. Public project page replaces the now-private API citation; original inspection date retained.
Campaign text and funding reviewed from the bundled Atlas snapshot; not a fresh retrieval of the campaign page. Funding is not delivery evidence.
Campaign text and funding reviewed from the bundled Atlas snapshot; not a fresh retrieval of the campaign page. Funding is not delivery evidence.
Campaign text inspected in bundled Atlas snapshot. Hampherny Rico describes past collaboration; this is contextual evidence, not organisation funding.
Retained Atlas recovery/chain observation, not freshly refetched in this audit. Funding date uses claim/block timestamp, not archive discovery. Snapshot retained in the audit evidence; public explorer is the receipt reference.
Retained Atlas recovery/chain observation, not freshly refetched in this audit. Funding date uses claim/block timestamp, not archive discovery. Snapshot retained in the audit evidence; public explorer is the receipt reference.
Public source reopened for this audit. Preserved response SHA256 b71fdc31b6e5a50242eb069be0dfe4545dcf8d3a43dd25e18a2254a45e92f822. Creator statements and published artifacts are not independent execution or expenditure verification.